2010-09-24 97 views
28

我有以下的Scala代码。斯卡拉模式匹配混淆选项[任何]

import scala.actors.Actor 

object Alice extends Actor { 
    this.start 
    def act{ 
    loop{ 
     react { 
     case "Hello" => sender ! "Hi" 
     case i:Int => sender ! 0 
     } 
    } 
    } 
} 
object Test { 
    def test = { 
    (Alice !? (100, "Hello")) match { 
     case i:Some[Int] => println ("Int received "+i) 
     case s:Some[String] => println ("String received "+s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    (Alice !? (100, 1)) match { 
     case i:Some[Int] => println ("Int received "+i) 
     case s:Some[String] => println ("String received "+s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    } 
} 

Test.test后,我得到的输出:

scala> Test.test 
Int received Some(Hi) 
Int received Some(0) 

我期待输出

String received Some(Hi) 
Int received Some(0) 

有什么解释?

作为第二个问题,我得到unchecked警告上述如下:

C:\scalac -unchecked a.scala 
a.scala:17: warning: non variable type-argument Int in type pattern Some[Int] is unchecked since it is eliminated by erasure 
     case i:Some[Int] => println ("Int received "+i) 
      ^
a.scala:18: warning: non variable type-argument String in type pattern Some[String] is unchecked since it is eliminated by erasure 
     case s:Some[String] => println ("String received "+s) 
      ^
a.scala:22: warning: non variable type-argument Int in type pattern Some[Int] is unchecked since it is eliminated by erasure 
     case i:Some[Int] => println ("Int received "+i) 
      ^
a.scala:23: warning: non variable type-argument String in type pattern Some[String] is unchecked since it is eliminated by erasure 
     case s:Some[String] => println ("String received "+s) 
      ^
four warnings found 

我怎样才能避免警告?

编辑:谢谢你的建议。丹尼尔的想法是好的,但似乎并没有与泛型类型的工作,如下面

def test[T] = (Alice !? (100, "Hello")) match { 
    case Some(i: Int) => println ("Int received "+i) 
    case Some(t: T) => println ("T received ") 
    case _ => 
} 

的例子以下 错误遇到 警告:warning: abstract type T in type pattern T is unchecked since it is eliminated by erasure

回答

36

这是因为类型擦除。除了数组之外,JVM不知道任何类型参数。因此,Scala代码无法检查OptionOption[Int]还是Option[String] - 该信息已被删除。

您可以治好你的代码这种方式,虽然:

object Test { 
    def test = { 
    (Alice !? (100, "Hello")) match { 
     case Some(i: Int) => println ("Int received "+i) 
     case Some(s: String) => println ("String received "+s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    (Alice !? (100, 1)) match { 
     case Some(i: Int) => println ("Int received "+i) 
     case Some(s: String) => println ("String received "+s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    } 
} 

这样,你是不是测试的Option类型是什么,但什么内容类型是 - 假如有任何内容。 A None将落入默认情况。

+0

谢谢!其他答案也很好,包括Kevin提出的解决方法。但是,这似乎是修复我的代码没有太多重写的最优雅的方式。 – Jus12 2010-09-24 17:13:45

+0

你能为类属类型提出一个类似的解决方法吗?如: 'def test [T] =(Alice!?(100,“Hello”))match {case Some(t:T)=> println(“T received”); case _ => println(“别的东西收到”)}' – Jus12 2010-09-25 15:03:11

+1

@ Jus12这种方式是行不通的。你需要得到一个'm:Manifest [T]',然后如果m.erasure.isAssignableFrom(t.getClass())=>'做一些事情,如'Some Some(t:T)。 – 2010-09-25 20:50:29

8

有关类型参数的任何信息,只适用于编译时间,而不是在运行时(这被称为类型擦除)。这意味着在运行时Option[String]Option[Int]之间没有区别,所以类型Option[String]上的任何模式匹配也将匹配Option[Int],因为在运行时,两者都只是Option

由于这几乎总是不符合您的要求,所以您会收到警告。避免警告的唯一方法不是在运行时检查某些东西的泛型类型(这很好,因为它无法像你想要的那样工作)。

有没有办法来检查Option是否是Option[Int]Option[String]在运行时(比如果它是一个Some检查内容等)。

2

如前所述,你在这里反对擦除。

对于解决方案......这是正常使用Scala的演员来定义你很可能会发送的每个信息类型的案件类别:

case class MessageTypeA(s : String) 
case class MessageTypeB(i : Int) 

object Alice extends Actor { 
    this.start 
    def act{ 
    loop{ 
     react { 
     case "Hello" => sender ! MessageTypeA("Hi") 
     case i:Int => sender ! MessageTypeB(0) 
     } 
    } 
    } 
} 
object Test { 
    def test = { 
    (Alice !? (100, "Hello")) match { 
     case Some(MessageTypeB(i)) => println ("Int received "+i) 
     case Some(MessageTypeA(s)) => println ("String received "+s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    (Alice !? (100, 1)) match { 
     case Some(MessageTypeB(i)) => println ("Int received " + i) 
     case Some(MessageTypeA(s)) => println ("String received " + s) 
     case _ => 
    } 
    } 
}