很多反对我的直觉VBA二进制搜索强烈胜过一个Excel查找。至少在下面的场景中,120,000个6个字符的字符串均匀分布在3个工作表中。
Excel查找需要1分58秒,
VBA二分查找在我的特定机器上需要36秒。
了解文本的顺序显然胜过Excel的天然优势。请注意Aladin A对排序顺序的警告。
Option Explicit
' Call Search to look for a thousand random strings
' in 3 worksheets of a workbook
' requires a workbook with 3 sheets and
' column A populated with values between "00001" to "120000"
' split evenly 40,000 to a worksheet in ascending order.
' They must be text, not numbers.
Private Const NUM_ROWS As Long = 120000
Private Const SHEET_1 As String = "Sheet1"
Private Const SHEET_2 As String = "Sheet2"
Private Const SHEET_3 As String = "Sheet3"
' This uses VBA Binary Search
Public Sub Search()
Worksheets(SHEET_1).Range("B:B").ClearContents
Worksheets(SHEET_2).Range("B:B").ClearContents
Worksheets(SHEET_3).Range("B:B").ClearContents
DoSearch True ' change to False to test Excel search
End Sub
' Searches for a thousand values using binary or excel search depending on
' value of bBinarySearch
Public Sub DoSearch(ByVal bBinarySearch As Boolean)
Debug.Print Now
Dim ii As Long
For ii = 1 To 1000
Dim rr As Long
rr = Int((NUM_ROWS) * Rnd + 1)
If bBinarySearch Then
Dim strSheetName As String
Dim nRow As Long
If BinarySearch(MakeSearchArg(rr), strSheetName, nRow) Then
Worksheets(strSheetName).Activate
Cells(nRow, 1).Activate
End If
Else
If Not ExcelSearch(SHEET_1, MakeSearchArg(rr)) Then
If Not ExcelSearch(SHEET_2, MakeSearchArg(rr)) Then
ExcelSearch SHEET_3, MakeSearchArg(rr)
End If
End If
End If
ActiveCell.Offset(0, 1).Value = "FOUND"
Next
Debug.Print Now
End Sub
' look for one cell value using Excel Find
Private Function ExcelSearch(ByVal strWorksheet As String _
, ByVal strSearchArg As String) As Boolean
On Error GoTo Err_Exit
Worksheets(strWorksheet).Activate
Worksheets(strWorksheet).Range("A:A").Find(What:=strSearchArg, LookIn:=xlValues, LookAt:=
xlWhole, SearchOrder:=xlByRows, SearchDirection:=xlNext, MatchCase:=True
, SearchFormat:=False).Activate
ExcelSearch = True
Exit Function
Err_Exit:
ExcelSearch = False
End Function
' Look for value using a vba based binary search
' returns true if the search argument is found in the workbook
' strSheetName contains the name of the worksheet on exit and nRow gives the row
Private Function BinarySearch(ByVal strSearchArg As String _
, ByRef strSheetName As String, ByRef nRow As Long) As Boolean
Dim nFirst As Long, nLast As Long
nFirst = 1
nLast = NUM_ROWS
Do While True
Dim nMiddle As Long
Dim strValue As String
If nFirst > nLast Then
Exit Do ' Failed to find search arg
End If
nMiddle = Round((nLast - nFirst)/2 + nFirst)
SheetNameAndRowFromIdx nMiddle, strSheetName, nRow
strValue = Worksheets(strSheetName).Cells(nRow, 1)
If strSearchArg < strValue Then
nLast = nMiddle - 1
ElseIf strSearchArg > strValue Then
nFirst = nMiddle + 1
Else
BinarySearch = True
Exit Do
End If
Loop
End Function
' convert 1 -> "000001", 120000 -> "120000", etc
Private Function MakeSearchArg(ByVal nArg As Long) As String
MakeSearchArg = Right(CStr(nArg + 1000000), 6)
End Function
' converts some number to a worksheet name and a row number
' This is depenent on the worksheets being named sheet1, sheet2, sheet3
' and containing an equal number of vlaues in each sheet where
' the total number of values is NUM_ROWS
Private Sub SheetNameAndRowFromIdx(ByVal nIdx As Long _
, ByRef strSheetName As String, ByRef nRow As Long)
If nIdx <= NUM_ROWS/3 Then
strSheetName = SHEET_1
nRow = nIdx
ElseIf nIdx > (NUM_ROWS/3) * 2 Then
strSheetName = SHEET_3
nRow = nIdx - (NUM_ROWS/3) * 2
Else
strSheetName = SHEET_2
nRow = nIdx - (NUM_ROWS/3)
End If
End Sub
谢谢。在52000个可能性(单张)内搜索1000个示例的测试案例中,Excel搜索的搜索时间为17秒,二进制搜索的搜索时间为5.5秒。揉搓是二分查找失败的25%时间。我认为问题在于excel的排序方式与VBA的“>”和“<”比较有所不同。 – ExcelCyclist 2009-12-13 15:13:59
是否有shell的记录,二进制搜索很好! 2000个随机例子,其中36秒(excel查找)中的52000行与11秒(二元查找)中的查找结果一致。 – ExcelCyclist 2009-12-13 23:29:17